27 Classic Thanksgiving Pies Worth Making

27 Classic Thanksgiving Pies Worth Making

Total
3
Shares

I am so ready for pie season, and honestly, these recipes are the best of the best. From pumpkin and pecan to peanut butter and everything in between, I’ve rounded up 13 insanely easy Thanksgiving pies and tarts that will totally steal the show on your holiday table. Trust me, you’re going to want to make every single one.

1. Pear and Almond Tart

This might just be the prettiest Thanksgiving pie recipe on the whole list. The combination of almond frangipane with the pears is incredible, and the apricot glaze makes the whole thing pop. It might not be a classic, but I have a feeling it will become a family staple.

Go to Recipe →

2. Toffee Almond Pie

Pecan pie is always top of the list during the holiday with its crunchy top and gooey center. This pie has all the same textures and a very similar filling. The critical difference is that it uses almonds. The sliced almonds provide a wonderfully crisp texture with each bite.

Go to Recipe →

3. No-Bake German Chocolate Pie

German chocolate cake is wonderfully moist and dark with that unique coconut and pecan topping. And this German chocolate pie is no different. Between the luxurious ganache filling and the nutty top, it is beyond decadent. Serve it with whipped cream, and your guests will go wild.

Go to Recipe →

4. Cranberry Orange Custard Pie

As much as I adore the classics like apple, pecan, and pumpkin, I really love putting out something a little different. This cranberry and orange pie is packed with fresh, tart cranberries and a silky smooth orange custard that balances all that sourness beautifully. The custard bakes right in the shell, and you don’t even have to blind bake the crust.

Go to Recipe →

5. Butternut Squash Pie

Swapping in butternut squash for pumpkin, or even using a little of both, is such a lovely change as we get closer to the holidays. The taste is really similar, but I find butternut squash is often easier to get my hands on. It bakes up into one seriously tasty Thanksgiving pie. I love serving this with a big dollop of whipped cream or a scoop of vanilla ice cream.

Go to Recipe →

6. Gingersnap Cranberry Lime Pie

This one is definitely not your typical pie for Thanksgiving, but it so should be. It is filled with flavor and is absolutely beautiful. The crust is a mix of gingersnaps, walnuts, butter, and brown sugar, and it doesn’t need to be rolled. Just press it into the pie dish and bake.

Go to Recipe →

7. Cinnamon Pie

This recipe is basically a cinnamon spiced cheesecake, and it is not for the faint at heart. It is creamy, sweet, and absolutely packed with cinnamon. You know that incredible smell when you walk into a craft store in the winter? They took that smell and turned it into this pie.

Go to Recipe →

8. No-Bake Butterscotch Pie

With a Biscoff cookie crust, a no bake butterscotch filling, and brown sugar cinnamon whipped cream on top, this pie is genuinely dangerous. One slice is never, ever enough for me. And that dreamy toffee drizzle takes it right over the top. The best part is that since it’s no bake, it won't hog any precious oven space. That’s what I call a total win win.

Go to Recipe →

9. Apple Cheddar Pie

Ok, hear me out! Apple and cheddar works. It just works, and you really should give it a go. I’m not talking about adding a block of cheese to the apple filling, I’m not a monster. But this pie does have cheese in the crust and just a little with the apples.

Go to Recipe →

10. Honey Pie

This pie’s creamy custard is flavored with honey for something wonderfully different but equally as delicious. Custard pies are simple, smooth, and incredibly moreish. I love that this recipe uses honey for something totally out of the box. I think you’ll love it too.

Go to Recipe →

11. Salted Caramel Pumpkin Pie

If you know me, you know I have a slight obsession with salted caramel. So when my love for salted caramel and my favorite fall pumpkin can come together, I am absolutely there. This recipe gives you a perfectly spiced and smooth pumpkin pie, and it actually mixes salted caramel right into the filling.

Go to Recipe →

12. Lemon Meringue Pie

You might not think of lemon meringue pie as a festive Thanksgiving dessert, but I think it’s ideal. In a sea of heavy, rich foods, this pie is wonderfully light and zippy. This version has a layer of creamy cheesecake along with plenty of gooey meringue on top. Every single bite is better than the last.

Go to Recipe →

13. Spiced Plum Pie

The color of this pie alone makes it worthy of your holiday table. Not to mention the fact that it’s vegan. And while plum might not be in your top Thanksgiving pie ideas, nobody will be able to resist a slice. I think it’s best served warm with ice cream.

Go to Recipe →

Total
3
Shares
Total
3
Share
error: Content is protected !!