I've gathered 20 of my favorite ways to turn those pillowy pastel Peeps into the most cheerful Easter desserts you ever did see. From cupcakes to milkshakes and everything in between, these sweet little marshmallow treats bring all the sugary, colorful fun your holiday table could ask for. Let’s dive into all the irresistible Peeps magic together!
1. Peeps S’mores
Got a basket overflowing with Peeps and you’re not exactly sure what to do with them all? I won’t judge if you eat them straight from the package, but there’s a better way.
Turn those leftover cuties into the gooiest, most adorable Peeps s’mores. It’s the perfect answer for using up every last bunny and chick while satisfying that sweet craving in the most fun way possible.
2. Easter Bunny Bundt Cakes
These adorable little bundt cakes get finished with a swoop of vanilla buttercream and a marshmallow Peep on top, making them absolutely perfect for Easter. I’m such a fan of bundt cakes because they give you permission to not strive for perfection. You can play, get creative with the decorations, and just have a blast.
3. Homemade Marshmallow Peeps
If you’re a Peeps superfan and Easter is your absolute favorite, making your own marshmallow treats will send you right over the moon. Store bought is fine, but homemade marshmallow is way easier than you’d imagine.
You can shape and color them however you like, and the whole process is just a blast. It’s the ultimate way to customize a classic candy.
4. Peeps Easter Pudding Cups
If you’re looking for a fun little project to keep tiny hands busy, these Easter pudding cups are it. They double as the cutest post egg hunt snack, too.
Just grab some pudding cups, any flavor works, line up a bunch of colorful toppings, and let the kids go wild building their own creations. It’s a sweet, easy, and totally adorable activity.
5. Easter Peeps Pops
If you need a last minute lifesaver that still feels special, these Easter Peeps pops are it. They’re quick, they’re easy, and they bring a whole lot of happy to your table with hardly any effort.
Plus, this one’s so simple that you can absolutely get the kids in on the fun. A little love and a few minutes, that’s all.
6. Peep Trifle
This Peep trifle is the kind of dessert that stops everyone in their tracks at the holiday table. It’s bright, colorful, and ridiculously simple to assemble.
Layer cake, Cool Whip, and pudding, then crown the whole thing with a rainbow of Peeps. It’s light, packed with flavor, and so beautiful that seconds are pretty much guaranteed.
7. Swimming Peeps Jell-O Cups
I literally can’t glance at these swimming Peeps Jell-O cups without breaking into a grin. They’re that cheerful!
These little guys are more than just adorable; they’re surprisingly yummy, with vibrant colors that make the whole dessert pop. It’s such a creative spin on regular Jello, and I think they’d be a total hit at a pool party, too.
8. Peeps Popcorn Balls
Need a simple, party ready dessert that’s also a total conversation starter? Rainbow Peeps popcorn balls to the rescue.
The ingredient list couldn’t be shorter: just popcorn, butter, and Peeps. They pull double duty as snacks and adorable party favors, especially for any rainbow themed celebration. Way more fun than a plain bowl of popcorn, I promise.
9. Easter Dirt Cake
My favorite thing about Easter has always been the desserts. I’ve loved Peeps ever since I was little, and honestly, I never grew out of it.
This Easter dirt cake brings together two childhood classics: creamy, crumbly dirt cake and those marshmallow y Peeps. Every scoop is layers of pure creamy, crunchy joy. So easy, and so, so delicious.
10. Twinkie Bunny Cars
Want to roll into Easter with the most playful dessert ever? Let me introduce Twinkie bunny cars.
Seriously, how can you resist a treat that pairs Twinkies with Peeps? It’s the fluffiest duo imaginable. You only need a handful of simple ingredients, things you likely already have in the pantry or can grab at the store, and they come out tasting absolutely amazing.
11. Peeps Cupcakes
Easter is pure joy, and I love any excuse to gather around the table with loved ones and dig into something sweet. These Peeps cupcakes are total showstoppers, the kind of treat that makes your dessert spread instantly cuter and so festive.
They come together so fast, it’s almost unbelievable, practically effortless yet completely irresistible. Your family will be wowed.
12. Peeps Brownie Bombs
Love brownies? Obsessed with Peeps?
These Peeps brownie bombs are about to rock your world. They hit that ideal sweet spot where rich, fudgy, deeply chocolatey brownie wraps itself around a light, airy marshmallow center. Every bite makes your tastebuds do a happy little dance.
13. Peep Brownies
My family goes all in on Easter and all the playful holiday eats. So when I spotted these little Peeps tucked into a blanket of brownie, it was an instant yes.
Imagine fudgy brownies topped with chocolate dipped marshmallow bunnies. Every bite is a happy mix of sweet, chewy, and rich. It’s pure fun for your tastebuds.
14. Chocolate Peanut Butter Marshmallow Peeps Fudge
You know what’s awesome? Peeps.
And what else is awesome? The classic duo of peanut butter and chocolate.
But the most awesome thing ever? Smashing them all together into one ridiculously easy fudge that practically makes itself. Next time a serious sweet craving hits, you know exactly what to do.
15. Chocolate Covered Peeps
Chocolate covered Peeps are the ultimate Easter treat. Sure, you can find them at the store, but homemade is a whole different league.
That moment when you bite through a snappy chocolate shell into the chewy, sugary marshmallow inside? Nothing beats it. It’s the most magical flavor combo.
16. Peeps Stuffed Chocolate Chip Cookies
Chewy chocolate chip cookies with a sweet, fluffy Peep hiding inside? That’s a match made in heaven.
If you’re after a gooey, chocolatey bite that instantly takes you back to childhood, these Peeps stuffed cookies are everything. I’m telling you, you will not be disappointed. Not even a little bit.
17. Easter Peeps Milkshakes
These Easter Peeps milkshakes are pure fun in a glass for the whole family. Just a few ingredients and a quick whirl in the blender, and you’ve got a dessert that both kids and grown ups go crazy for. Fair warning: once you try one, regular milkshakes might just feel a little boring.
18. Peeps Cookie Bars
I adore Easter Peeps. They’re bright, pillowy, and pure sugary happiness.
But I’m also a total sucker for a classic chocolate chip cookie bar, that nostalgic comfort food. So naturally, I asked myself: can I have both at the same time? The answer is a big, enthusiastic yes, and these Peeps cookie bars deliver.
19. Peeps Eclair Cake Cups
Everyone loves dessert, and it’s a million times better when it’s no fuss, am I right? These party Peeps eclair cake cups are here to save the day.
Simple, speedy to put together, and guaranteed to be a crowd pleaser. They’re the easiest little cups of creamy, dreamy goodness.
20. Peeps Rice Krispie Treats
Peeps are an Easter icon, but I get it, sometimes they can be a bit much on their own. The fix?
Turn them into Rice Krispie Treats! Swap out regular marshmallows for these pastel cuties, and suddenly you’ve got a batch of perfectly pastel, crispy, gooey squares. It’s a genius way to dial the sweetness into something totally irresistible.